Topic Sponsor
2009 - 2014 Ford F150 General discussion on 2009 - 2014 Ford F150 truck.
Sponsored by:
Sponsored by:

Compressor cycling fix

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 08-11-2015, 09:16 AM
  #841  
Senior Member
 
digitaltrucker's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Texas
Posts: 11,570
Received 2,238 Likes on 1,710 Posts

Default

Originally Posted by Engineer Guy
Thanks to the fabulous Info on this Thread, I finally got around to my own quick & dirty Mod using a 500k Pot w/integral On/Off Switch from Radio Shack.

In the Engineering Trades, my Testing today was intentionally confined to 'Proof Of Principle': 1. Does the Pot I chose work? 2. Does it work on my Year/Model of Truck? 3. Did I achieve what we used to call 'The Desired End Results'? I.e., a much lower and wider range of Temps out my A/C Vents?

Mission Accomplished!

Because I could not make reliable temporary connections at the Connector leading to the embedded Thermistor, I used my old Troubleshooting trick of shoving 2 Push Pins through the Wires. I ran thin Wire ~3' out to the Pot. I don't have time for a Spreadsheet, so here's my Test Results.

2014 STX SCab 4x4 - 5.0 Liter - Manual Single Zone A/C - No Sunlight Sensor by Windshield - Factory R-134a Charge - not Gauge verified. Uncalibrated Radio Shack Indoor/Outdoor Thermometer. Thermometer Outside Temp Sensor stuck in Vent immediately to Driver's Right. Temp readings below were logged after ~5 minute Test intervals.

Outside Temp in Cloudy Weather - 81 F Degrees

Cabin Humidity - 22 %

Cabin Temp - 84 F

Vent Temp Setpoints - Stock - 44.3 F 'Low' - 47.4 F 'High' during Compressor cycling.

'MAX A/C' setting w/Recirc used at all times in stationary Truck. Loud Aux Radiator Fan on ~70% of the time. Again, this Test was restricted to only Pot-related effects; not a full range of findings. Like, what is the outcome of a long drive, or what is the outcome in 105 F Degree Weather? In my experience, it is critical to reduce the number of Variables during Test in order to reach reproducible conclusions.

~450k Ohms Pot setting didn't have 'much' effect. Perhaps an A/C Vent Temp of a degree or two less; relative to the Stock Setpoints above.

~250k Ohms Pot setting - 39.4 F 'Low' - 41.7 F 'High' Compressor Cycling

~125k Ohms Pot setting - 34.3 F 'Low' - 36.9 F 'High' Compressor Cycling

Testing was then terminated to avoid potential freezing. Given the low Humidity, there was no liquid pooling under Truck when I moved it. My Cellphone and Voltmeter were actually cold to the touch when I moved them after ~1 hour of Testing. As we established in College, what a difference a little Pot can make!-)

A ~$3.50 Pot from Radio Shack, and the amazing wisdom in this Thread, led to a drop of exactly 10 F Degrees in Truck Vent Temp output! I will not keep Vent Temps that low. However, it's nice to know what's possible; and it verifies the lower 'end point' possible with this Mod. Also, note that Compressor On/Off Temp spread was reduced. I also really liked the 'new' alternative of directing A/C Air Flow to both my Feet and my Torso. This was not possible prior because Vent Temps were too high to cool both Cabin regions to comfortable levels.

The pending, final Install will use a Ford Harness to attach this Pot to. I will wire through the integral Pot On/Off Switch to remove this parallel Resistance from the Thermistor Circuit seasonally. I will use an old Guitar Amplifier Volume **** mounted discretely to provide a relative adjustment reference. I chose the 2 Pot Tabs whereby clockwise rotation - higher Resistance - results in relatively higher Cabin temp/Compressor Cycling Temp Setpoints.

I like the relative quiet of Outside A/C vs. Recirc, or Max Air. Air. Drawing in Outside Air using 'Regular' A/C Mode led to higher Vent Temps during Test of about 3 F Degrees while stationary. I will use 'Max A/C' Mode initially to cool a Heat-soaked Cabin, or in high outside temps.

As one can see in the excellent Calculations and Info nicely provided up-Thread, the Thermistor takes very low current. This is why the Wires to it are so small. No need to worry about Wire length/size to an outboard Pot, or to use any Heat Sinking. FYI, Thermistors are commonly used in House HVAC Thermostats, for example.

I've insulated my A/C 'Cold' line; as documented in my Write-Up here elsewhere. I also plan to retrofit ~R-7 'Astrofoil' - a.k.a. 'Reflectix' - behind my SCAB Rear Seat, and in the Doors, as I upgrade my OEM A/V System.

Thanks - and thanks again - to all the tenacious Contributors here. I had my first Ham Radio Station at age 12, and built large P.A. Systems after College. Spent most of my Career in precision Measurement Instrumentation, and Electronics. The range of generous Info in this Thread really floated my proverbial Boat!

We're away soon in our new RV Trailer in early Retirement. I'll report in with any long Trip A/C perturbations, or pertinent findings. I'm guessing that clicking off the Pot - then clicking it back on - will cause the A/C Temps to drop again; removing the vexing long Trip problem where this Pot solution works so well initially, then sometimes doesn't. As with most Electronic/Control Systems, resetting or rebooting often corrects abnormal System behaviors.
.
My sentiments exactly. While I was hoping for a permanent fix for this issue, had it not been for the 1 meg pot, this summer would be horrible for the donor truck in Houston this summer.

Its turning out to be a "great" in town fix! As far as the road, we have yet to return the donor truck to a total charge of 29 ounces. (5 ounces over the Ford charge of 24.) Remember we had some good results with the slight OC that makes the long road trips OK, without the pot.

As you have stated, the units run colder and most importantly, dont have the wild swing when the compressor is cycling on/off. Prior to the pot, the donor truck using max air could barely blow cold on days in the high 90's. Now with the pot, the donor truck can achieve cold air without using max.

Last edited by digitaltrucker; 08-11-2015 at 09:18 AM.
The following users liked this post:
Engineer Guy (08-11-2015)
Old 08-12-2015, 03:58 PM
  #842  
Senior Member
 
celltech's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: NW Minnesota
Posts: 312
Received 49 Likes on 40 Posts

Default

Mine was rocking today. 90 and sunny, 346k ohm resistor, line wrapped. 35 out the vents on my short 10 minute drive in town to work.
The following 2 users liked this post by celltech:
digitaltrucker (08-12-2015), Engineer Guy (08-13-2015)
Old 08-12-2015, 10:03 PM
  #843  
Member
iTrader: (1)
 
TheSlimOne's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2013
Location: Fort Worth, TX
Posts: 66
Received 14 Likes on 10 Posts

Default

I am running a 470k ohm resistor, here in DFW its been about 100-106. The A/C is doing SO much better. It runs about 42 or so out the vents. I used to have to keep it at full blast non stop to feel like it was doing much. Now after a couple of minutes I can turn it down a bit. Why the hell does ford think that this is ok. JUST NUTS!

I may drop the resistor down a bit. I dunno. I am pretty happy with the way it operates so far.
The following 2 users liked this post by TheSlimOne:
digitaltrucker (08-12-2015), Engineer Guy (08-13-2015)
Old 08-12-2015, 11:18 PM
  #844  
Oooo a Custom Title.
 
LOCO LAPTOP's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Coral Springs, FL
Posts: 1,066
Received 108 Likes on 73 Posts

Default

Originally Posted by TheSlimOne
I am running a 470k ohm resistor, here in DFW its been about 100-106. The A/C is doing SO much better. It runs about 42 or so out the vents. I used to have to keep it at full blast non stop to feel like it was doing much. Now after a couple of minutes I can turn it down a bit. Why the hell does ford think that this is ok. JUST NUTS!

I may drop the resistor down a bit. I dunno. I am pretty happy with the way it operates so far.
Same here on the 470K ohm. The other night I had it on low because it was freezing my *** off. It's even colder when its cool outside.
The following users liked this post:
Engineer Guy (08-13-2015)
Old 08-14-2015, 09:58 AM
  #845  
Member
 
Engineer Guy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: Western Colorado
Posts: 85
Received 23 Likes on 21 Posts

Default

From LOCO LAPTOP...

'It's even colder when its cool outside.'

The lil Radio Shack Indoor/Outdoor Thermometer w/Humidity Sensor I'm hauling around in a Cup Holder just off the Floor has become the most important Gauge I'm referencing, vs. a new DVM. Job #1 is determine the Vent Temp -> Cabin Temp when comfortable. Job #2 is to correlate Pot [or Resistor] Ohmage to makes that comfort happen.

I've managed to make a lil Ice in my A/C when Vent Temp hit ~38.5 F. It blew out of a Vent, like flicking the top of a Snowcone. When I immediately shut off A/C, and kept the Fan on, I could hear 'something' drop within the System [Frost]. Cabin Humidity lept up to ~58% from ~24% as this Frost melted. Things returned to normal in a few minutes. No harm/no foul. The second time I made a lil Ice/Frost, the Cabin Temp climbed quickly; suggesting that insulating Frost was impeding 'Cold' exchange. Vent Temps were cycling from 38.5 F -> 40.4 F when this suddenly happened. It appears to take 'some' time... I suspect that the tipping point of Frost creation is due to Cabin Temp steadily dropping while on 'Recirc'.

So, if Resistor Value 'x' is netting Temps in the low 40s, I'd suggest that's perhaps as low as you want to go. Nothing succeeds like success. I'm gonna test on into the Fall, since Colder In -> Colder Out. Meanwhile, when Cabin Temps hits the mid-60s [amazing!], the System does a great job of increasing Vent Temp 'some' to maintain this. I assume this is the Thermistor/Circuitry to the Dash right side of the Steering Wheel doing it's job.

While Idling in 90 F Degrees with the Vent Temp around 40 F, I suddenly couldn't get the Vent Temp below 50 F to save me. 'High' Radiator Fan setting never kicked on. I first thought I'd lost a connection in my Homeboy Wiring setup. Nope. Nor was the System creating Frost. Only driving away made my System drop back to the high 30s - low 40s. This was all on 'Recirc' with Fan on '4'. Not much 'MAX A/C' anymore. No need, EXCEPT for the first few minutes IF the Cabin's Heat Soaked. Like, the ~110 F Cabin Temp I hopped into yesterday. MAX A/C drops Vent Temps another degree or so. This makes freezing more likely. No Kids/No Wife driving my Truck to damage things, so I'm gonna tweak away on Pot settings throughout the ~400k Ohms range.

Reducing Fan Speed changes Air Flow, and thus 'Cold' being conducted away. I'm still playing with that factor while watching Vent Temps.

The 500k Ohms Radio Shack Pot I'm dinkin' with has lil index 'clicks'. So, my Sweet Spot Temp setting is 2 or 3 'clicks' CCW back from the 500k Ohms at full CW. This is in my 2014 SCab with Factory [minimal] Window Tint. I eventually want to seasonally set my System via Pot indexing 'clicks' vs. carrying a Temp Gauge forever.
The following users liked this post:
digitaltrucker (08-14-2015)
Old 08-14-2015, 10:02 AM
  #846  
Senior Member
 
Old Smoky's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2012
Posts: 1,362
Received 233 Likes on 158 Posts

Default

Originally Posted by Engineer Guy
From LOCO LAPTOP...

'It's even colder when its cool outside.'

The lil Radio Shack Indoor/Outdoor Thermometer w/Humidity Sensor I'm hauling around in a Cup Holder just off the Floor has become the most important Gauge I'm referencing, vs. a new DVM. Job #1 is determine the Vent Temp -> Cabin Temp when comfortable. Job #2 is to correlate Pot [or Resistor] Ohmage to makes that comfort happen.

I've managed to make a lil Ice in my A/C when Vent Temp hit ~38.5 F. It blew out of a Vent, like flicking the top of a Snowcone. When I immediately shut off A/C, and kept the Fan on, I could hear 'something' drop within the System [Frost]. Cabin Humidity lept up to ~58% from ~24% as this Frost melted. Things returned to normal in a few minutes. No harm/no foul. The second time I made a lil Ice/Frost, the Cabin Temp climbed quickly; suggesting that insulating Frost was impeding 'Cold' exchange. Vent Temps were cycling from 38.5 F -> 40.4 F when this suddenly happened. It appears to take 'some' time... I suspect that the tipping point of Frost creation is due to Cabin Temp steadily dropping while on 'Recirc'.

So, if Resistor Value 'x' is netting Temps in the low 40s, I'd suggest that's perhaps as low as you want to go. Nothing succeeds like success. I'm gonna test on into the Fall, since Colder In -> Colder Out. Meanwhile, when Cabin Temps hits the mid-60s [amazing!], the System does a great job of increasing Vent Temp 'some' to maintain this. I assume this is the Thermistor/Circuitry to the Dash right side of the Steering Wheel doing it's job.

While Idling in 90 F Degrees with the Vent Temp around 40 F, I suddenly couldn't get the Vent Temp below 50 F to save me. 'High' Radiator Fan setting never kicked on. I first thought I'd lost a connection in my Homeboy Wiring setup. Nope. Nor was the System creating Frost. Only driving away made my System drop back to the high 30s - low 40s. This was all on 'Recirc' with Fan on '4'. Not much 'MAX A/C' anymore. No need, EXCEPT for the first few minutes IF the Cabin's Heat Soaked. Like, the ~110 F Cabin Temp I hopped into yesterday. MAX A/C drops Vent Temps another degree or so. This makes freezing more likely. No Kids/No Wife driving my Truck to damage things, so I'm gonna tweak away on Pot settings throughout the ~400k Ohms range.

Reducing Fan Speed changes Air Flow, and thus 'Cold' being conducted away. I'm still playing with that factor while watching Vent Temps.

The 500k Ohms Radio Shack Pot I'm dinkin' with has lil index 'clicks'. So, my Sweet Spot Temp setting is 2 or 3 'clicks' CCW back from the 500k Ohms at full CW. This is in my 2014 SCab with Factory [minimal] Window Tint. I eventually want to seasonally set my System via Pot indexing 'clicks' vs. carrying a Temp Gauge forever.
I pretty much have the same set up and seeing the same results, except I'm around 500K now. Anything 95 and below, it works like a real normal A/C should. Heat soaked and 105, it labors to cool down for a while. On the interstate it eventually settles in on MAX then I can kick it back to norm high.
The following users liked this post:
Engineer Guy (08-14-2015)
Old 08-14-2015, 11:29 AM
  #847  
Senior Member
 
digitaltrucker's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Texas
Posts: 11,570
Received 2,238 Likes on 1,710 Posts

Default

OK I am going to throw this out to everyone now. Have you noticed since your coil is cooler now, the "dirty sock smell"?
The following users liked this post:
Engineer Guy (08-14-2015)
Old 08-14-2015, 11:37 AM
  #848  
Senior Member
 
MDBoostWorks's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2015
Location: Maryland
Posts: 136
Received 104 Likes on 42 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by digitaltrucker
OK I am going to throw this out to everyone now. Have you noticed since your coil is cooler now, the "dirty sock smell"?
That would be from more condensation in your evaporator box, when you park the truck any condensation that doesn't drain out will form some mildew and cause the funky smell. Probably really strong when you first start the truck and turn the air on then diminishes right?
The following users liked this post:
Engineer Guy (08-14-2015)
Old 08-14-2015, 11:40 AM
  #849  
Senior Member
 
digitaltrucker's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Texas
Posts: 11,570
Received 2,238 Likes on 1,710 Posts

Default

Originally Posted by MDBoostWorks
That would be from more condensation in your evaporator box, when you park the truck any condensation that doesn't drain out will form some mildew and cause the funky smell. Probably really strong when you first start the truck and turn the air on then diminishes right?

Actually, no. We can be driving along in the donor truck and one of the wives will say: Theres that smell coming from the AC!

So no not on start up at all, but that is the norm.
The following users liked this post:
Engineer Guy (08-14-2015)
Old 08-14-2015, 11:42 AM
  #850  
Senior Member
 
MDBoostWorks's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2015
Location: Maryland
Posts: 136
Received 104 Likes on 42 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by digitaltrucker
Actually, no. We can be driving along in the donor truck and one of the wives will say: Theres that smell coming from the AC!

So no not on start up at all, but that is the norm.
Now that is interesting, haven't seen that one yet.


Quick Reply: Compressor cycling fix



All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:20 PM.