Glad it worked for you when I bought my truck it was rattling like crazy I was missing the drivers side but the passenger side had the cone shaped one . When I went to buy them the guy at the Fords part counter said to get the square ones he had people complain about the cone shaped ones after a while they got too soft to help keep the door from bouncing like crazy.

 

Yeah, the barrel shaped ones are much stiffer and just from closing my door a few times I can tell it takes more force to close. The cone shaped ones are pretty flimsy. So I think these will do the trick.

 

hmm.....has this not worked for anyone? I just bought these and installed them and still have the same amount of rattle out of the driver side rear door.

 

As soon as I saw this thread, I immediately went and checked the rubber bumpers in my truck. They were really soft and squishy. Ordered the ones pictured above and put them in today.

You have no idea how nice it is to drive and not have all of my doors (supercrew ftw!) rattle like they aren't closed. THANK YOU!

 

I dont know if you have a SuperCrew or a SuperCab, so first thing I'll ask is did you replace the rear door bumpers as well as the front? At first I didn't even realize the rear doors in my SuperCab HAD the bumpers, they are down at the very bottom of the doors. I had to bend way over to even see 'em. But now that I've had them in a week or two I can definitely see (feel, and hear) a big difference in my truck. I give this little tip a BIG 'Ol two thumbs up!