rebuild or replace engine
Hello,
My name is Ángel Alvarado owner of a 2010 F150 that has been sitting in my driveway for over a year. I have little to no mechanical knowledge, other than changing the oil, the occasional flat tire and headlight, and trying to keep the truck clean. I bought this used 2010 F150 in 2015 from a Ford dealer and tootled around in it because I like F150s. This is my third F150 having had a '79 and a '91 in previous years.
I simply joined this forum because I am looking for advice on what to do with my 2010.
The last time the truck ran was when I drove to a shop to find out what the pinging/knocking sound was coming from my engine. Long story short, the mechanics took off what looks like the cap of the engine and told me the engine was shot, that I needed a new one, and was quoted 10K+ if I wanted them to do the work. I used my insurance's towing benefit to tow it home and it's been on the driveway since then. I have now saved up some cash for the engine work, but I am questioning the wisdom of it in terms of cost over benefit, new engine, used engine, have it rebuilt, etc. I don't even know how to start shopping around for this kind of work, what can I expect for my money, and how do I know how well the job is being done, let alone the kind a guarantee I can expect.
Any advice will be kindly accepted.
Thank you in advance!
My name is Ángel Alvarado owner of a 2010 F150 that has been sitting in my driveway for over a year. I have little to no mechanical knowledge, other than changing the oil, the occasional flat tire and headlight, and trying to keep the truck clean. I bought this used 2010 F150 in 2015 from a Ford dealer and tootled around in it because I like F150s. This is my third F150 having had a '79 and a '91 in previous years.
I simply joined this forum because I am looking for advice on what to do with my 2010.
The last time the truck ran was when I drove to a shop to find out what the pinging/knocking sound was coming from my engine. Long story short, the mechanics took off what looks like the cap of the engine and told me the engine was shot, that I needed a new one, and was quoted 10K+ if I wanted them to do the work. I used my insurance's towing benefit to tow it home and it's been on the driveway since then. I have now saved up some cash for the engine work, but I am questioning the wisdom of it in terms of cost over benefit, new engine, used engine, have it rebuilt, etc. I don't even know how to start shopping around for this kind of work, what can I expect for my money, and how do I know how well the job is being done, let alone the kind a guarantee I can expect.
Any advice will be kindly accepted.
Thank you in advance!
Last edited by aja; Mar 11, 2021 at 12:05 AM.
How many miles did you have on it?
Some good advice already given, get a 2nd and 3rd opinion and worse case scenario sell it “as is” and look for another truck. Spend 10k on a truck that is only worth 10k if it was running, that’s hard to swallow.
Some good advice already given, get a 2nd and 3rd opinion and worse case scenario sell it “as is” and look for another truck. Spend 10k on a truck that is only worth 10k if it was running, that’s hard to swallow.
aja ...
» Edit Signature «.
.
All those questions are things you’ll have to have a face to face with any shops you talk to.
A 2-valve 4.6 won’t be anywhere near that pricey. I’m betting you are stuck with a 3-valve 4.6 or 5.4. A swap to a remanufactured engine should still only cost about half your quoted cost as long as you aren’t padding a Ford dealer’s monthly margin.
In short, if potentially eating several thousand bucks is a big deal right now, it might be time to trade up. I wouldn’t go with a used 3-valve engine.
A 2-valve 4.6 won’t be anywhere near that pricey. I’m betting you are stuck with a 3-valve 4.6 or 5.4. A swap to a remanufactured engine should still only cost about half your quoted cost as long as you aren’t padding a Ford dealer’s monthly margin.
In short, if potentially eating several thousand bucks is a big deal right now, it might be time to trade up. I wouldn’t go with a used 3-valve engine.
10k for an engine swap in a 2010 f150. That's the I don't want to do the work but will for this price quote. Go to another shop or 3 and get some quotes. Hell you can probably get rough estimates with a few phone calls.










