AAA came out and it took them about 20 minutes to do both the door and the ignition. Its going to get me by for now. I'm pretty pissed that they didn't actually make me a true replacement key. They just took a few key rings with a total of about 400 keys and started testing each one. One guy started on the door and the other started on the ignition. Once they found two keys that worked, they smashed them together and out came a key that looked like poop. A few days later, I drove out to my in-laws house. Their neighbor is a locksmith. I showed him the key they made and he was telling me that they did it completely wrong. They basically jimmy-rigged a key that works, but it doesn't even look like my old key.

I wouldn't have called them if the keys were in the car, it was just that I lost the keys all together. Oh well, I learned my lesson.

They saying still holds true, "you get what you pay for"