Major Sludge Found Under Valve Cover
#131
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Update
Finished extracting carb cleaner out of head bolt holes using a siphon gun I had and taping a 5/16" diameter fuel line hose from HD to it. Then used just the hose assembly with my shop vac to do a thorough clean after giving the holes a pass with a thread chaser. Thanks ceasefire49! All my compressors are at jobsites.
Time has been fleeting with work and the recent long weekend but the next few days should prove productive.
Have right side head installed and just need to do final torque down on the bolts before moving on to the left side.
Pulled the PCV type connector on left side of intake manifold and found it fully sludged up. I think this engine is almost sludge free now.
Time has been fleeting with work and the recent long weekend but the next few days should prove productive.
Have right side head installed and just need to do final torque down on the bolts before moving on to the left side.
Pulled the PCV type connector on left side of intake manifold and found it fully sludged up. I think this engine is almost sludge free now.
#132
Moderator
Keep up the good work! Can't wait to see a video of this thing hopefully purr to life!
#133
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Well, I guess things were going a little too smooth. Broke a head bolt when doing final torque down. Either bolt was faulty or torque wrench was way off.
Will have to pick up a screw extractor set, remove head and get to work. Never done this before so will be going slow.
Now I know why the ARP studs are highly recommended.
One question, can I reuse the head gasket on that side? It was bolt #2 in sequence so the other 8 were only very snug.
Will have to pick up a screw extractor set, remove head and get to work. Never done this before so will be going slow.
Now I know why the ARP studs are highly recommended.
One question, can I reuse the head gasket on that side? It was bolt #2 in sequence so the other 8 were only very snug.
#134
LightningRod
I would say yes. I might divide the tightening sequence into a couple of extra tightening sequences before doing final torque to yield.
The way you cleaned head bolt holes, the part remaining might not be that tight in the threads. It might back out fairly easily without removing the head if your extractors will reach... (hopefully ... !)
#135
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Thanks Torqued. Will be trying that this evening. I think I'll swap the one set of head bolts for a fresh set.
Picked up a new torque wrench which ranges from 10-150 ft/lbs so should be safe to hit 30 for the head bolts and 18 for some of the other bolts including the timing parts.
Read not very accurate near the beginning or end of a torque wrench's range. Previous one was 30-200.
Picked up a new torque wrench which ranges from 10-150 ft/lbs so should be safe to hit 30 for the head bolts and 18 for some of the other bolts including the timing parts.
Read not very accurate near the beginning or end of a torque wrench's range. Previous one was 30-200.
#137
Good God does not one know what sludge is or where it comes from?
Sludge is basically water got into the oil. Either through defective PCV parts, excessive blow by, or not running the engine up to temp.
Now a days oils alone isn't the cause of sludge.. there are additives to prevent it... but after so much water and oil mix they become ineffective.
Don't throw away the motor until you find out true cause. That's a $2-5k+ mistake.
First, replace all PCV parts. Check that all hoses are clear and not cracked.
Second, do a compression (or better) a leakdown test to see if there are and piston ring/cylinder issues.
Lastly, pressure test the coolant system to check for leaks.
The first issue is an easy fix. Depending on if/where you find the leak #3 could be easy or a devastating (a cracked waterjacket is not something I would want to fix).
If you have a low piston than its up to you... it is fixable for cheap if you can do it yourself and depending on what the issue is.
Sludge is basically water got into the oil. Either through defective PCV parts, excessive blow by, or not running the engine up to temp.
Now a days oils alone isn't the cause of sludge.. there are additives to prevent it... but after so much water and oil mix they become ineffective.
Don't throw away the motor until you find out true cause. That's a $2-5k+ mistake.
First, replace all PCV parts. Check that all hoses are clear and not cracked.
Second, do a compression (or better) a leakdown test to see if there are and piston ring/cylinder issues.
Lastly, pressure test the coolant system to check for leaks.
The first issue is an easy fix. Depending on if/where you find the leak #3 could be easy or a devastating (a cracked waterjacket is not something I would want to fix).
If you have a low piston than its up to you... it is fixable for cheap if you can do it yourself and depending on what the issue is.
#138
05 5.4l 3v s.crew lariat
you may have run in to the bad china bolts
There have been a lot of bad bolts getting into our system . The military and utilities have been fighting this for awhile . Case hardened bolts being junk . I can't imagine a head bolt breaking at 30 foot pounds . That torque wrench would have to be way off . Not that anyone couldn't get a bad bolt . Are these bolts one time use like the phasors /crank .
I don't think it's good to torque one bolt all the way down . I would do all bolts a little at a time in sequence ,the same as you do cams .
Is it procedure to put a little engine oil on threads ? I really don't know myself but I would think so . I will wait for the experts on that .
I don't think it's good to torque one bolt all the way down . I would do all bolts a little at a time in sequence ,the same as you do cams .
Is it procedure to put a little engine oil on threads ? I really don't know myself but I would think so . I will wait for the experts on that .
#139
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Good God does not one know what sludge is or where it comes from?
Sludge is basically water got into the oil. Either through defective PCV parts, excessive blow by, or not running the engine up to temp.
Now a days oils alone isn't the cause of sludge.. there are additives to prevent it... but after so much water and oil mix they become ineffective.
Don't throw away the motor until you find out true cause. That's a $2-5k+ mistake.
First, replace all PCV parts. Check that all hoses are clear and not cracked.
Second, do a compression (or better) a leakdown test to see if there are and piston ring/cylinder issues.
Lastly, pressure test the coolant system to check for leaks.
The first issue is an easy fix. Depending on if/where you find the leak #3 could be easy or a devastating (a cracked waterjacket is not something I would want to fix).
If you have a low piston than its up to you... it is fixable for cheap if you can do it yourself and depending on what the issue is.
Sludge is basically water got into the oil. Either through defective PCV parts, excessive blow by, or not running the engine up to temp.
Now a days oils alone isn't the cause of sludge.. there are additives to prevent it... but after so much water and oil mix they become ineffective.
Don't throw away the motor until you find out true cause. That's a $2-5k+ mistake.
First, replace all PCV parts. Check that all hoses are clear and not cracked.
Second, do a compression (or better) a leakdown test to see if there are and piston ring/cylinder issues.
Lastly, pressure test the coolant system to check for leaks.
The first issue is an easy fix. Depending on if/where you find the leak #3 could be easy or a devastating (a cracked waterjacket is not something I would want to fix).
If you have a low piston than its up to you... it is fixable for cheap if you can do it yourself and depending on what the issue is.
Have the PCV system fully cleaned, and will be doing a leak down test when I have the heads on and engine put together. Also will be doing a full cooling system flush when ready to fire and then will probably do a pressure test. There wasn't any sign of a leak, but wouldn't write it off.
There have been a lot of bad bolts getting into our system . The military and utilities have been fighting this for awhile . Case hardened bolts being junk . I can't imagine a head bolt breaking at 30 foot pounds . That torque wrench would have to be way off . Not that anyone couldn't get a bad bolt . Are these bolts one time use like the phasors /crank .
I don't think it's good to torque one bolt all the way down . I would do all bolts a little at a time in sequence ,the same as you do cams .
Is it procedure to put a little engine oil on threads ? I really don't know myself but I would think so . I will wait for the experts on that .
I don't think it's good to torque one bolt all the way down . I would do all bolts a little at a time in sequence ,the same as you do cams .
Is it procedure to put a little engine oil on threads ? I really don't know myself but I would think so . I will wait for the experts on that .
Yes you put some oil on the threads and some under the bolt head.
Haven't attempted the bolt extractor just yet. Tried with a flathead screwdriver as there is a bit of ridge on half the bolt, but no go. Soaked it with Deep Creep tonight and will attempt hammering an old chisel tomorrow and see if it will turn. It's a good 3½" down so if I have to drill, I'll have my work cut out for me.
#140
05 5.4l 3v s.crew lariat
I have removed bolts from engines with extractors
Key is to use brand new drill bits the best you can find . Try to keep it centered on the bolt shaft ,center punch it, start small, clean out hole often don't risk breaking bit .
Hope this doesn't slow you up much as we are waiting to see a very good outcome .
Hope this doesn't slow you up much as we are waiting to see a very good outcome .
The following users liked this post:
Ecobuilder (06-02-2017)