Put these P275x60x20 Toyo AT2's on about 10K miles ago. Lightweight tire with decent offroad traction and look's like a truck tire. Still able to get up to 19-20mpg hwy and 17 in town...not as heavy as the LT tires I've been running so performance and braking are not affected either...kind of the best of both world's if you're not planning on towing anything heavy or going on work or job sites. Good wet traction and not noisy on the highway...rolling resistance is not as good as highway tread tires and mileage loss from the stock Pirelli's may be up to 1 mpg.

 

On my previous vehicle I replaced my Michelin all-weather with Cooper Zeon LTZ's. Better looking, just as smooth on the road, barely louder and much better in the sand.

My two cents