Repair or replace?
#1
Repair or replace?
I took my '14 f150 in for a brake job at he dealer and asked them to investigate a transmission shudder problem at highway speed. It was also hard shifting from 1-2 and 2-3 during the winter. After the brake job, they concluded the auto tranny's clutch unit was going out and they recommended a complete replacement of the transmission, costing $4,800. They said just fixing the problem would not be a good idea because the new trans would have a 3 year warranty, versus 2 years only on the replaced parts but no guess on what the repair would cost until they tore into it. I chose to pay for the brake job and think about it.
Some background: About a year ago, I had a rough idle and it was determined that a compression problem in one cylinder would require a new head. That was done under warranty before 100k rolled up. So the engine is running well with a new head.) Now the truck has 120K miles.
So, what would you do? Sink $5k into a new transmission or buy a new truck? I had hoped to keep this one a couple more years until I retire.
Some background: About a year ago, I had a rough idle and it was determined that a compression problem in one cylinder would require a new head. That was done under warranty before 100k rolled up. So the engine is running well with a new head.) Now the truck has 120K miles.
So, what would you do? Sink $5k into a new transmission or buy a new truck? I had hoped to keep this one a couple more years until I retire.