View Poll Results: Specifically for the 2004-2008 5.4L V8 Triton, what oil do YOU use?
0W-40
9
1.06%
5W-20
474
55.76%
5W-30
289
34.00%
5W-40
18
2.12%
10W-30
33
3.88%
10W-40
13
1.53%
Any of them, it doesn't matter
5
0.59%
Other
9
1.06%
Voters: 850. You may not vote on this poll
5.4L Engine Oil - "What Should I Use?"
#321
Senior Member
iTrader: (1)
Wow this debate still rages on!!
Very simple answer/advice incoming!!!
From someone who will no longer debate this topic while full well knowing the very slight differences between the 2 oils. (I.E.:: Research the 2 oil weights and see).....
5w-30 is more shear stable than 5w-20...
In hotter or milder climates 5w-30 is the safest bet for year round protection with a heavy duty film strength. ESPECIALLY in the 5.4 3v.
If you even anticipate Higher temps, longer trips, or varied climate throughout the year... choose 5w-30.
5w-20 film strength is quite good compared to 5w-30. But it's not better.
Cooler climates, short trips and a softer worked engine, mostly commuting. 5w-20 is fine.
But if you even work that engine hard for 1-2 days a year, you better believe that 5w-20 is offering less protection than 5w-30 at the operating environments extremes with a stock 195 degree T stat..
Now It just so happens that the 5.4 3v has it's own unique set of cascading issues and failures. All dependent on a reliable oil circuit delivering a robust oil from the crank to the heads, through the cam phaser to the tensioners.. At 1 point or another one of these connected pathways will experience an issue due to a flat out poor design.. Not a terribly bad design, just not ideal at all.
When any of these components begin to excessively wear, elevate friction, or leak, you are now demanding more from that lighter duty "skinnier" film strength offered by 5w-20 at operating temp.
Well check around, the 5.4 3v is notorious for having several oil circuit related issues..
Lash adjusters wearing down, or seizing..
crank shaft thrust washers wearing down, or falling completely out and into the pan..
Phasers veins leaking, locking pin damage, low oil pressure feeding and bleeding issues, higher internal friction, and sometimes just flat out oil starvation (vct solenoids issues/plugged valve body).
Tensioner seals rupturing, leaking.
Plastic chain Guides breaking introducing tiny little wear particles amongst many other unrelated particulate.
Valve seals leaking (inevitable)
Keeper/follower rollers wearing down(inevitable)
Lash adjusters wearing down, leaking, and or seizing.. (inevitable)
Timing chain tensioners leaking (inevitable)
Broken chain guides from cold start "chain slap" (inevitable)
Ford's terrible and leak prone crankshaft thrust washer design failure (inevitable)
Minus all the oddity's revolving around the blanket spec of North American 5w-20..................
At least in my mind, and in my own whipple supercharged 5.4 3v that is new with only 20k on it. 60k miles supercharged on my old 5.4 3v up to 195k before a lash adjuster seized and caused a dropped valve on cylinder 3.
I still highly recommend most 5.4 3v owners use 5w-30.
When it comes to protection..
I'd rather be looking at IT than looking for IT with the 5.4 3v..
I think the most naive thing to do is to discount the facts and evidence while owning this engine.
Very simple answer/advice incoming!!!
From someone who will no longer debate this topic while full well knowing the very slight differences between the 2 oils. (I.E.:: Research the 2 oil weights and see).....
5w-30 is more shear stable than 5w-20...
In hotter or milder climates 5w-30 is the safest bet for year round protection with a heavy duty film strength. ESPECIALLY in the 5.4 3v.
If you even anticipate Higher temps, longer trips, or varied climate throughout the year... choose 5w-30.
5w-20 film strength is quite good compared to 5w-30. But it's not better.
Cooler climates, short trips and a softer worked engine, mostly commuting. 5w-20 is fine.
But if you even work that engine hard for 1-2 days a year, you better believe that 5w-20 is offering less protection than 5w-30 at the operating environments extremes with a stock 195 degree T stat..
Now It just so happens that the 5.4 3v has it's own unique set of cascading issues and failures. All dependent on a reliable oil circuit delivering a robust oil from the crank to the heads, through the cam phaser to the tensioners.. At 1 point or another one of these connected pathways will experience an issue due to a flat out poor design.. Not a terribly bad design, just not ideal at all.
When any of these components begin to excessively wear, elevate friction, or leak, you are now demanding more from that lighter duty "skinnier" film strength offered by 5w-20 at operating temp.
Well check around, the 5.4 3v is notorious for having several oil circuit related issues..
Lash adjusters wearing down, or seizing..
crank shaft thrust washers wearing down, or falling completely out and into the pan..
Phasers veins leaking, locking pin damage, low oil pressure feeding and bleeding issues, higher internal friction, and sometimes just flat out oil starvation (vct solenoids issues/plugged valve body).
Tensioner seals rupturing, leaking.
Plastic chain Guides breaking introducing tiny little wear particles amongst many other unrelated particulate.
Valve seals leaking (inevitable)
Keeper/follower rollers wearing down(inevitable)
Lash adjusters wearing down, leaking, and or seizing.. (inevitable)
Timing chain tensioners leaking (inevitable)
Broken chain guides from cold start "chain slap" (inevitable)
Ford's terrible and leak prone crankshaft thrust washer design failure (inevitable)
Minus all the oddity's revolving around the blanket spec of North American 5w-20..................
At least in my mind, and in my own whipple supercharged 5.4 3v that is new with only 20k on it. 60k miles supercharged on my old 5.4 3v up to 195k before a lash adjuster seized and caused a dropped valve on cylinder 3.
I still highly recommend most 5.4 3v owners use 5w-30.
When it comes to protection..
I'd rather be looking at IT than looking for IT with the 5.4 3v..
I think the most naive thing to do is to discount the facts and evidence while owning this engine.
Last edited by Especial86; 03-05-2018 at 10:44 AM.
The following 4 users liked this post by Especial86:
#322
Tried searching for Oil change info for 2006 5.4L, Having a difficult time removing the oil filter...Fram chain wrench turned it a bit but No help. Is Oil filter wrench (the circular cap one with nut head) the only option..if so i dont know which size to buy...The one on truck now...Pennzoil is smaller than the New Mobil one i have. Thanks in advance.
#323
Tried searching for Oil change info for 2006 5.4L, Having a difficult time removing the oil filter...Fram chain wrench turned it a bit but No help. Is Oil filter wrench (the circular cap one with nut head) the only option..if so i dont know which size to buy...The one on truck now...Pennzoil is smaller than the New Mobil one i have. Thanks in advance.
This is the exact one i bought for my 2009. I would not change my oil without it.
#324
Junior Member
Oil wrenches
Tried searching for Oil change info for 2006 5.4L, Having a difficult time removing the oil filter...Fram chain wrench turned it a bit but No help. Is Oil filter wrench (the circular cap one with nut head) the only option..if so i dont know which size to buy...The one on truck now...Pennzoil is smaller than the New Mobil one i have. Thanks in advance.
Last edited by FX4Marco; 03-11-2018 at 11:24 AM. Reason: Add info
#325
Member
Truck goes in for new plugs/boots and oil/filter tomorrow. I've used Mobil 1 Synthetic 5w-30 in all of my cars since 2003 & my '03 Escape had 257,000 miles on it when I traded it in on a Flex in 2014. The Escape ran great - I was just tired of looking at the same dashboard & used to commute 600 miles / week for years.
Costco just ran a sale (may still be on) so I got Mobil 1 for $4.50 / gt (two six packs). I bought a two-pack of Mobil 1 filters on Amazon for $25 so I'm set for a while. I always add a bottle of Marvel Mystery Oil & although some say it's snake oil it's never caused me any problems. Probably just psychological on my behalf.
Costco just ran a sale (may still be on) so I got Mobil 1 for $4.50 / gt (two six packs). I bought a two-pack of Mobil 1 filters on Amazon for $25 so I'm set for a while. I always add a bottle of Marvel Mystery Oil & although some say it's snake oil it's never caused me any problems. Probably just psychological on my behalf.
#327
Just noting that the F150 mobil1 filter has the bypass valve on the opposite end than the FL820S.
other
The F150 K&N filter has the bypass valve on the opposite end than the FL820S.
The F150 FramUlta filter has the bypass valve on the opposite end than the FL820S.
The F150 FORDRACING filter has the bypass valve on the SAME END as the FL820S.
.
Last edited by Fordjunkync; 06-02-2018 at 01:28 AM.
#328
The following users liked this post:
Fordjunkync (06-19-2018)
#329
I recently had an incident that brought me to this thread on oils. I live in Southern California and recently went camping in the Eastern Sierras. On the trip home, after diving for about 3 1/2-4 hours in 100 degree heat. my oil pressure went to zero. After sitting, for about 20 minutes, I restarted and was able to drive another five miles before the same thing happened again but this time with a "rattling" noise. I stopped, had the truck picked up and taken to my mechanic the next day. He was unable to find anything wrong with the vehicle and suggested I add Lucas Oil Stabilizer, and/or use 10w30 instead of the 5w20. The truck is a 2006 and has 156,000 miles on it, and has not lost the oil pressure again, although I have only used it for short trips to work or running errands. One friend says the oil pump is at fault, and another thinks maybe the oil pick up was blocked temporarily. Yet another says that with the heat I was driving in, the oil lost it's viscosity and wasn't able to do its job.
So do I change to 10w30? Add the Lucas Oil Stabilizer? Stay with 5w20? Or...?
So do I change to 10w30? Add the Lucas Oil Stabilizer? Stay with 5w20? Or...?
Last edited by Drago17; 08-14-2018 at 07:21 AM. Reason: spelling
#330
Moderator
I recently had an incident that brought me to this thread on oils. I live in Southern California and recently went camping in the Eastern Sierras. On the trip home, after diving for about 3 1/2-4 hours in 100 degree heat. my oil pressure went to zero. After sitting, for about 20 minutes, I restarted and was able to drive another five miles before the same thing happened again but this time with a "rattling" noise. I stopped, had the truck picked up and taken to my mechanic the next day. He was unable to find anything wrong with the vehicle and suggested i add Lucas Oil Stabilizer, and/or use 10w30 instead of the 5w20. The truck has 156,000 miles on it, and has not lost the oil pressure again, although I have only used it for short trips to work or running errands. One friend says the oil pump is at fault, and another thinks maybe the oil pick up was blocked temporarily. Yet another says that with the heat I was driving in, the oil lost it's viscosity and wasn't able to do its job.
So do I change to 18w30? Add the Lucas Oil Stabilizer? Stay with 5w20? Or...?
So do I change to 18w30? Add the Lucas Oil Stabilizer? Stay with 5w20? Or...?