2017 F150 v. F250
#21
Senior Member
Like others said if you tow, especially around 10k pounds on a regular basis get a 3/4 ton truck.
I never had a F-250 but I did own several Ram 2500 CTD. I did tow a 8K trailer with my truck once. Sure it has enough power to it but it never felt really stable despite the fact that I wasn't near the rated limit. I towed the same with the Ram CTD and you didn't even know there was a trailer behind it. I am certain the F-250 will deliver a similar experience (except for the MPGs).
I never had a F-250 but I did own several Ram 2500 CTD. I did tow a 8K trailer with my truck once. Sure it has enough power to it but it never felt really stable despite the fact that I wasn't near the rated limit. I towed the same with the Ram CTD and you didn't even know there was a trailer behind it. I am certain the F-250 will deliver a similar experience (except for the MPGs).
Last edited by 71_340; 02-21-2018 at 07:39 PM.
#22
The 250 is the most ridiculous thing, I cannot imagine a situation where you would want one.
150 or 350.
The price difference between a 250 and a 350 are minimal.
Our fleet is 150 or 350 only, the 250 just doesn't make sense.
150 or 350.
The price difference between a 250 and a 350 are minimal.
Our fleet is 150 or 350 only, the 250 just doesn't make sense.
The following users liked this post:
chimmike (02-23-2018)
#24
Be careful on the door latch issue. When I dropped my F150 they were dealing with Latch issues on SD as well. Not as common but I expect by next winter you will see plenty. Although I didn’t verify it sounded like they are the exact same parts. No dog in this race.
If stepping up to SD I agree 110% go F350. I previously had F350 and switched to newer F250 and never liked the way it towed in comparison. I had 11.5’ Lance camper and 3500# boat. F350 was a pleasure the F250 with helper springs required lots more attn to be safe. Stopping, swaying as Semi’s passed, and winds felt unstable.
If stepping up to SD I agree 110% go F350. I previously had F350 and switched to newer F250 and never liked the way it towed in comparison. I had 11.5’ Lance camper and 3500# boat. F350 was a pleasure the F250 with helper springs required lots more attn to be safe. Stopping, swaying as Semi’s passed, and winds felt unstable.
#25
Im no heavy duty truck expert but i was always under the impression the 250 is perfect for people like op who tow here and there and dont really need the extra capacity of a 350. The 350 is not much more because its probably just beefier springs and shock(total guess) and because of that the 350 would be a pretty harsh ride unloaded? Im your neighbor in Calgary so like you every other vehicle is a truck lol and of all the 250/350 or 2500/3500 that i see on the road most are the 250/2500
#26
Im no heavy duty truck expert but i was always under the impression the 250 is perfect for people like op who tow here and there and dont really need the extra capacity of a 350. The 350 is not much more because its probably just beefier springs and shock(total guess) and because of that the 350 would be a pretty harsh ride unloaded? Im your neighbor in Calgary so like you every other vehicle is a truck lol and of all the 250/350 or 2500/3500 that i see on the road most are the 250/2500
I personally see more 350 than 250's on the road. This, of course, is circumstantial to my personal observations.
As for fleet, I never see 250 trucks.
#27
I haven't paid much attention to the SuperDuty line since selling my F450 5 years ago, but there's one nearby that has me thinking.
However when I start looking at cab size, payload and towing I see that a F150 Ecoboost KR 157 with max towing and max payload has virtually the same capability as a F250 gas CCLB KR.
Don't tell me about diesel, I've reached my lifetime maximum of 16 qt oil changes.
only material differences would be 48 gal fuel tank which is negated by fuel mileage if you look at range and ability to get to 15k towing with 4.30 gears and there are none out there.
However when I start looking at cab size, payload and towing I see that a F150 Ecoboost KR 157 with max towing and max payload has virtually the same capability as a F250 gas CCLB KR.
Don't tell me about diesel, I've reached my lifetime maximum of 16 qt oil changes.
only material differences would be 48 gal fuel tank which is negated by fuel mileage if you look at range and ability to get to 15k towing with 4.30 gears and there are none out there.
#29
Senior Member
I considered a Super Duty when I bought my '17 XLT. I specifically searched based on towing around a 6k TT loaded. I stuck with XLT because it does have higher payload. My truck has a payload of 1783lbs. This is more than sufficient for my needs. I decided against the Super Duty due to the harsh ride. Also, if I wanted to stay in budget, I would have had to get an XL in the Super Duty. If I ever move up to a 5th wheel, there is no doubt I would get the Super Duty.
Another thing about towing, that rarely gets mentioned, is tires. Tires can make all the difference in towing stability. LT tires will have a mushy feeling compared to a 10-ply heavy duty set of tires. Yes they 10-ply will add weight, but that weight also helps with stability under load.
Another thing about towing, that rarely gets mentioned, is tires. Tires can make all the difference in towing stability. LT tires will have a mushy feeling compared to a 10-ply heavy duty set of tires. Yes they 10-ply will add weight, but that weight also helps with stability under load.
#30
Senile member
I don't have numbers to back it up, but I believe that a 350 has a better resale value, simply because they are more in demand. The 250 is some weird middle step child, haha.
I personally see more 350 than 250's on the road. This, of course, is circumstantial to my personal observations.
As for fleet, I never see 250 trucks.
I personally see more 350 than 250's on the road. This, of course, is circumstantial to my personal observations.
As for fleet, I never see 250 trucks.