would you do electric fan addition to 2005 f150 5'4
#1
05 5.4l 3v s.crew lariat
Thread Starter
would you do electric fan addition to 2005 f150 5'4
After rebuilding front of engine timing etc ,I can see it would be helpful to get clutch fan and shroud out of the way for good .
If I need to work on pulleys ,alt or water pump-- removing that fan is a pain .
It is worth the money and trouble?
The new trucks have it . I'm looking at the extreme ffd system on ebay with red dual fans . I live in fla and I do some occasional towing . At 380 bucks that's not too bad. I would probrably want a sensor in radiator hose also even though the ac is usually on in my truck so that wiring to fan clutch would keep the fans on most of the time .
I don't know about the quality of the controller they use and since its always hot here I know that's a killer of electronics .
I want a dependable system with warranty not concerned with gas mileage or show looks . Not too impressed with the open wires I see on some installs .
If I need to work on pulleys ,alt or water pump-- removing that fan is a pain .
It is worth the money and trouble?
The new trucks have it . I'm looking at the extreme ffd system on ebay with red dual fans . I live in fla and I do some occasional towing . At 380 bucks that's not too bad. I would probrably want a sensor in radiator hose also even though the ac is usually on in my truck so that wiring to fan clutch would keep the fans on most of the time .
I don't know about the quality of the controller they use and since its always hot here I know that's a killer of electronics .
I want a dependable system with warranty not concerned with gas mileage or show looks . Not too impressed with the open wires I see on some installs .
#2
After rebuilding front of engine timing etc ,I can see it would be helpful to get clutch fan and shroud out of the way for good .
If I need to work on pulleys ,alt or water pump-- removing that fan is a pain .
It is worth the money and trouble?
The new trucks have it . I'm looking at the extreme ffd system on ebay with red dual fans . I live in fla and I do some occasional towing . At 380 bucks that's not too bad. I would probrably want a sensor in radiator hose also even though the ac is usually on in my truck so that wiring to fan clutch would keep the fans on most of the time .
I don't know about the quality of the controller they use and since its always hot here I know that's a killer of electronics .
I want a dependable system with warranty not concerned with gas mileage or show looks . Not too impressed with the open wires I see on some installs .
If I need to work on pulleys ,alt or water pump-- removing that fan is a pain .
It is worth the money and trouble?
The new trucks have it . I'm looking at the extreme ffd system on ebay with red dual fans . I live in fla and I do some occasional towing . At 380 bucks that's not too bad. I would probrably want a sensor in radiator hose also even though the ac is usually on in my truck so that wiring to fan clutch would keep the fans on most of the time .
I don't know about the quality of the controller they use and since its always hot here I know that's a killer of electronics .
I want a dependable system with warranty not concerned with gas mileage or show looks . Not too impressed with the open wires I see on some installs .
This is NOT an upgrade you want to save pennies on: no cooling, no workee.
You want OEM MC RF-269's and a high-quality, constant-temperature variable-speed controller to match. Either DCC or Painless F5's.
Several detailed build threads on this site fer the searchin'.
good luck
MGD
Last edited by MGD; 06-02-2016 at 11:06 AM.
#3
05 5.4l 3v s.crew lariat
Thread Starter
thanks mgd I'm going to do some more research
found RF252's on rock auto I guess they are dual numbered 269 . I would go with them and the painless F5's . I am worried I would have to change out alternator to a 200 amp . Don't know what that would cost .
I run air cond almost all the time in fla. so Both fans would run all the time . I don't know if there is some speed sensor tie in on the 2005 that would cutout the fans at cruise . Will have to brain storm this some more .
Found a video of modification to fans and mount , to mount these to my existing radiator without fan shroud .
Will also count my money for this big job . Still recovering from rebuild. Sure would be nice to get that area all opened up .
I run air cond almost all the time in fla. so Both fans would run all the time . I don't know if there is some speed sensor tie in on the 2005 that would cutout the fans at cruise . Will have to brain storm this some more .
Found a video of modification to fans and mount , to mount these to my existing radiator without fan shroud .
Will also count my money for this big job . Still recovering from rebuild. Sure would be nice to get that area all opened up .
#4
I am worried I would have to change out alternator to a 200 amp . Don't know what that would cost .
I don't know if there is some speed sensor tie in on the 2005 that would cutout the fans at cruise .
Will also count my money for this big job . Still recovering from rebuild. Sure would be nice to get that area all opened up .
#6
But be real. Electric fan is way to go, why do you think Ford is heading this way since 2009?
#7
Senior Member
Agreed, a clutch fan is loud for a few moments. The electric fans were loud every time the AC cycled.
Plus, there is extra load on the alternator, that ain't free ya know.
Is Ford using 'brushless' technology in their electric fans? I can see how that would be more efficient that a clutched fan or traditional electric fans.
Plus, there is extra load on the alternator, that ain't free ya know.
Is Ford using 'brushless' technology in their electric fans? I can see how that would be more efficient that a clutched fan or traditional electric fans.
Last edited by Taildragger; 06-08-2016 at 10:06 PM.
Trending Topics
#8
Moderator (Ret.)
I've been running the same used (purchased it used in 2006) Mark VIII 2 speed fan for 10 years now. The fan and its controller were first installed on my 2005 F-150, then switched to a Ranger, and then swapped to my current 2007 F-150. Same electric motor, different controllers.
I started with a DCC controller in the 2005, ran that setup for 3 years. Removed the setup from that truck when I sold it. I sold the DC controller to someone on this site, as I did not think I'd need the setup anymore. I then purchased a Ron Francis controller for use in the Ranger, and the same Mark VIII fan. That remained in the Ranger (my son still drives it) with a new fan. I took out the Mark VIII fan and installed it in my current 2007 F-150, and am now using Flex-O-Lites controller. Absolutely no issues with any of the controllers, other then long delays can be experienced with getting a DC controller, and if you email with complaints or concerns, it can/will make it worse. Use PayPal in case you have to file a dispute and request a refund. MGD, I respect your loyalty with Brian Baskin at dc control, but folks should be aware that there are many issues others have had with his customer service.
Whatever you do, use a controller! Never wire an e-fan to a battery or switch directly!
I started with a DCC controller in the 2005, ran that setup for 3 years. Removed the setup from that truck when I sold it. I sold the DC controller to someone on this site, as I did not think I'd need the setup anymore. I then purchased a Ron Francis controller for use in the Ranger, and the same Mark VIII fan. That remained in the Ranger (my son still drives it) with a new fan. I took out the Mark VIII fan and installed it in my current 2007 F-150, and am now using Flex-O-Lites controller. Absolutely no issues with any of the controllers, other then long delays can be experienced with getting a DC controller, and if you email with complaints or concerns, it can/will make it worse. Use PayPal in case you have to file a dispute and request a refund. MGD, I respect your loyalty with Brian Baskin at dc control, but folks should be aware that there are many issues others have had with his customer service.
Whatever you do, use a controller! Never wire an e-fan to a battery or switch directly!
Last edited by Mod (Ret.); 06-09-2016 at 07:40 AM.
#9
Member
Agreed, a clutch fan is loud for a few moments. The electric fans were loud every time the AC cycled.
Plus, there is extra load on the alternator, that ain't free ya know.
Is Ford using 'brushless' technology in their electric fans? I can see how that would be more efficient that a clutched fan or traditional electric fans.
Plus, there is extra load on the alternator, that ain't free ya know.
Is Ford using 'brushless' technology in their electric fans? I can see how that would be more efficient that a clutched fan or traditional electric fans.
Last edited by bbrad1775; 06-09-2016 at 03:05 PM.
#10
Senior Member
The Flex a lite draws an average of 28 amps, maybe not the 17 hp claims it frees up but significant.
I been there, done that. Went back stock due to no noticeable advantages.
Now, if the manufactures were to adopt brushless technology, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brushl...electric_motor
and only draw 1/4 or less of the amps of a conventional brushed motor the advantages would be very attractive. Maybe this is what the factory Ford is now.
We are talking about ten year old F-150s here, spend your money anyway you like.
I been there, done that. Went back stock due to no noticeable advantages.
Now, if the manufactures were to adopt brushless technology, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brushl...electric_motor
and only draw 1/4 or less of the amps of a conventional brushed motor the advantages would be very attractive. Maybe this is what the factory Ford is now.
We are talking about ten year old F-150s here, spend your money anyway you like.