morehousej

I'm not a fan of weathertechs, but they, as well as Huskys don't warp and peel away, and both are very flexible, so that point is nil to justify the extra cost.
I will add that I have never tried the Edgeliners myself, so yes they may be a superior product.
I would be willing to provide a very honest review and comparison with my Husky and weathertech experiance if you would like to send me a set for my truck.

bwFX42006

I had weathertech in my 2006 SCAB FX4. Just bought a complete set of Huskyliners for my 2012 SCAB FX4. Only $162 on amazon and I couldn't be happier. (Backseat liner was a little shy of each side but who cares, never have backseat passengers anyway.)

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0...?ie=UTF8&psc=1

Spiky

Not bad. Nice there's another player in the high end liners market. But there are still spots where carpet can get dirty, don't fool yourself.

Yours are slightly cleaner than mine right now.

cmbezln

Hey EdgeLiner, I'm always up for doing a review if you're still feeling generous!

STingray1300

When I complain about something, it's not to put someone else's choice down, but to give the "other side of the coin" information for others to make an informed choice.

Now, that said, I will say that I will never waste my money on the Digi-Fit Weathertechs again. I had a full set in a car a few years ago, and it only takes a single season to trash them. The raised edges, that are supposed to create a "bucket" to catch water, etc. went limp and would not stay up. Then a passenger steps on it and they're done. The mats themselves warp badly and even when cleaned, look terrible. And to add to all this, their Weathertech labels peel off. No class. Oh, and WeatherTechs answer to the concerns? Nothing. They won't even talk to you or email a reply to you if you ask about your order (and why it's taking so long).

So far, Husky is a much better liner. But I still am very happy with my OEM mats...

WXman

My Husky Liners did, in fact, curl up in cold weather and pull away. It was quite annoying. I know that folks up north get colder than we do here in KY, but we do go well below zero at times and my Husky Liners were a PITA to be honest. The thing I liked about the Huskys was the look.

My WeatherTech liners didn't get affected by the weather as much, but they were somewhat hard and unflexable. I didn't have any real trouble out of them. But removing them to vacuum under the carpet was a slight pain because they were a harder material and they would catch on things worse than Christmas lights when I'd try to remove them.

The EdgeLiners are indeed softer, easier to the touch, easier to install and pull back out. It's been record warm weather here lately, but in a week or two we're going back into the deep freeze so I'm anxious to see how they hold up to the cold...and to my size 13 Justin boots near the pedals all the time.

MrWizzard550

Those look pretty darn good to me! They look similar to mats I had in my '06 Tundra for the 10 years I owned the truck.
I'm looking forward to your future posts about the mats.

BobbyC

iTrader: (1)

I have Husky Weatherbeaters in the front and Weathertech in the rear (Screw) for the past 5+ years. I have 2 posts on the floor but the Weatherbeaters only has 1 slot on the left side so every once in a while, I think about getting a new set for the front. I never had them curl up in heat up to 105°F or cold down to 5°F. They've worked great but the Weathertechs in the back slide around a lot and can never get it to sit where it should. I have Weatherbeaters for the back too but they don't look as good.

Spiky

FWIW, I have the weatherbeaters in back and they never move.

morehousej

mine are the husky x-act contours, I guess that's one advantage to them, they have slots for both posts so they never move, but even my passenger side one never moves, the fit is perfect. and everything is covered. They have never lifted/curled on me, and they have seen temps from -45C to +38C and at +38C I have no idea how hot the inside the cab got, I swear my skin started to melt when I opened the door. I don't know how you Southern US guys handle that heat on a daily basis. I'll keep my sub freezing temps any day over that.